Keeping politics in games: How might Skydance’s purchase of Warner Bros affect the direction of travel for triple-A?

Rocksteady Studios’ Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League (2024) was caught in the Sweet Baby Inc controversy due to a perceived “woke” political agenda. The British developer is now owned by Skydance
By Rob Fahey
For the past quarter-century or more, there’s been a common refrain from a small but vocal segment of consumers: keep politics out of our videogames. While many of the same voices were a little incoherent in the related discussion about games as art – uncertain whether they were mad that anyone would claim games weren’t art, or whether they were instead mad at anyone trying to engage with them critically as art – the message about politics was at least consistent. Keep it out. It has no place in games.
Any veneer of sincerity within that position fell apart as soon as you interrogated what was actually meant by "politics," which almost inevitably boiled down to minority representation. Games depicting real-world wars, historical revolutions, or clashing ideologies in far-flung galaxies? Non-political. Games featuring gay people, or brown people you aren’t meant to use as target practice, or women whose design isn’t masturbation-optimal? Politics.
Am I grossly oversimplifying? Sure – no doubt some people genuinely were mad at BioShock for taking aim at Randian objectivism while having no strong feelings at all about female characters’ cup sizes, and I humbly apologise for lumping them in with the hoi polloi. On the whole, though, 'politics' spent many years being a hissed shibboleth for diversity, or, as its detractors would insist, forced diversity, whereby minority representation was being crowbarred into games by a powerful cabal who would happily destroy gaming itself in pursuit of their ideology.
The truth, of course, was embarrassingly self-evident, which is perhaps why it was such a bitter pill to swallow for some. Representation and diversity did improve in games, albeit sometimes clumsily, but the powerful cabal behind it were the CEOs and other executives of major publishers, who pushed for diversity for the same reason they push for anything: because it made money. Not only do people of all kinds buy games, it turns out, but even non-minorities tend to prefer games that reflect the world they live in and the people they know.
The ideology behind increasing diversity in games was capitalism all along. Whether you find that depressing or uplifting depends on your own ideology, but the commercial reality of it is undeniable. And that’s really where this story should end. Unfortunately, it seems like it may all have been a prologue to something far worse.
X-rated
The acquisition of Warner Bros by Skydance – the media empire run by David Ellison, son of right-wing billionaire Larry Ellison, which recently received a billion-dollar investment from Elon Musk – brings with it a huge stable of WB’s game studios, which have been merged with the smaller Paramount Games Studio operation that Skydance already owned. It follows on the heels of Electronic Arts’ leveraged buyout by a consortium that prominently features Donald Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner. In the space of a few months, two very major game publishers, along with their development studios and their IPs, have come under the ownership of media bosses who have shown little inclination to “keep politics out” of anything they control.
Some of what’s happening at those companies is just an inevitable consequence of the highly leveraged buyouts that have become such a blight on the corporate landscape over the past decade. Each of these newly acquired firms is burdened with billions of dollars of debt in the form of the loans that were taken out to buy them, and is expected to service that debt in large part by aggressively cutting costs – which means firing staff and also shutting studios. BioWare is the most high-profile casualty at EA to date, but the cuts may go even deeper at Warner Bros, which reportedly needs to find $6 billion in savings in the coming years.
Such circumstances might be expected to get these entities fired up to sell games to the widest possible audience, that the financial sword of Damocles hanging over their heads would have minds laser-focused on the same purely capitalist, commercial calculus that led companies to try to grow their markets and reach broader demographics in the first place. Who has time for a culture war when you’ve got to find $6 billion down the back of the sofa?
Perhaps that's how things will go, but the signs from how Skydance and its ilk have managed other media investments are not encouraging. After years of game companies being accused of putting ideology ahead of profits (a concept that could only be entertained by someone who’s never actually had to sit across a table from a publishing executive), we’re seeing what that actually looks like in reality at Ellison’s CBS News and Elon Musk’s Twitter: audiences falling, revenues collapsing, and billionaires at the helm for whom such numbers can be shrugged off as long as the ideology fits.

At the core of this lies a sense of grievance these tremendously wealthy men appear to feel about the world – grievance that often seems to fit with the same conspiratorial beliefs as the people who inhabit the most sludge-clogged backwaters of the media networks they own. The belief that diversity and representation were pushed for ideological reasons persists even though these are people who actually know the CEOs and other executives who led those companies, and thus know how hard-nosed their commercial decision-making has always been.
That belief allows them to frame their strategies, whether it’s cutting "DEI" or promoting "traditional values," as a bold push-back against years of "forced" diversity, even if what it actually amounts to is kicking the legs out from underneath what is, in the videogame business at least, the only half-decent engine of audience growth the industry has experienced for over a decade.
In truth, videogames have almost always been a politically conservative medium, with the vast majority of releases carefully hewing towards the social status quo; it was the movement of that status quo that a vocal minority was really railing against, not the corresponding games. It has been vanishingly rare for anything other than the occasional indie title to actually stand out as a political statement, and far more common to see games turn up feeling proud as punch about their groundbreaking representation so many years after it became commonplace in TV and film.
The takeovers at EA and Warner Bros threaten a new era in which bosses at major publishers are genuinely ideologically motivated and determined to turn games into a medium of socio-political influence. If that’s how this goes, the political impact will be muted – the world is simply too media-saturated for audiences not to find better options elsewhere – but the commercial impact could be severe. After half a decade of layoffs and closures across the industry, two major publishers being run into the ground for the political whims of billionaires would be catastrophic.
How odd, though. Now that ideological politics really does appear to threaten such a significant part of the industry, all those voices who decried politics in games for so long seem strangely silent.
